Religious Studies of the Media

Religious Studies of the Media

Assessing the Sociological Definition of Islamic Art Based on the Principles of Formal Logic: A Study of Ravadrad’s View

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Zohreh-Sadat Rahimifar PhD student in Art Research, Faculty of Advanced Art Studies and Entrepreneurship, University of Art, Isfahan, Iran
2 PhD in Islamic Art Wisdom, Assistant Professor, Department of Art Research, Institute of Islamic Art and Thought, Qom, Iran
10.22034/jmrs.2026.579718.1253
Abstract
Objective: Islamic art is one of the richest and most complex cultural fields in Islamic civilization. It has mostly been studied within historical and philosophical frameworks and much less from a sociological perspective. Azam Ravadrad, drawing on the sociology of art, has tried to offer a definition of Islamic art that can fill this theoretical gap. This study takes an analytical approach based on formal logic. It evaluates Ravadrad’s proposed definition and assesses how far it meets the logical criteria of a definition: comprehensiveness, exclusiveness, clarity, and avoidance of circularity.
Method: The study uses a descriptive-analytical method, and the data were collected from library sources.
Findings: The results show that Ravadrad’s emphasis on divine content draws a relatively clear boundary between Islamic art and other artistic types, which satisfies exclusiveness. However, too much focus on this component limits the definition’s comprehensiveness, because it excludes some decorative works and works without a specific meaning from the domain of Islamic art. The definition also relies on concepts such as “the general spirit of Islamic civilization” and “audience perception.” Because of the role of religious elites in the process of recognition, and because these criteria are subjective and unstable, they reduce the definition’s clarity and usefulness. Even so, the definition is acceptable in terms of avoiding circularity.
Conclusion: The most important challenge for Ravadrad’s definition is that it does not fully meet the formal principles of definition. A more precise, balanced, and coherent framework is still needed to explain the nature of Islamic art.
Keywords