Religious Studies of the Media

Religious Studies of the Media

A Comparative Study of the Function of Mise-en-scène in Portraying the Infallibles in the Television Series Imam Ali and the Film Muhammad: The Messenger of God

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Media Arts, Faculty of Religion and Media, IRIB University, Qom, Iran
2 Master of Arts in Television Production, Department of Media Arts, Faculty of Religion and Media, IRIB University, Qom, Iran
Abstract
Objective: This study compares the function of mise-en-scène in portraying the Infallibles (al-Maʿṣūmin) in two landmark works of Iranian television and cinema: the television series Imam Ali and the feature film Muhammad: The Messenger of God. Specifically, it examines how visual and kinetic elements, including set design, costume design, lighting, and makeup, are used to represent these sacred figures.
Method: The study adopts a neoformalist approach to compare the mise-en-scène strategies of the two works. Data were collected through systematic observation and close analysis of selected scenes, with particular attention to their visual and kinetic dimensions. This analysis was designed to identify the strengths and weaknesses of each work’s direction in its use of mise-en-scène.
Findings: The analysis reveals that the director of Imam Ali concentrated primarily on visual elements such as set design, costume, and lighting. By comparison, makeup and the other components of mise-en-scène remained underdeveloped. The series therefore makes limited use of the more complex dimensions of mise-en-scène and relies mostly on simpler visual strategies. In contrast, the director of Muhammad: The Messenger of God uses the full repertoire of mise-en-scène effectively. Set design and lighting in particular foreground the spiritual attributes of the infallible figures and considerably strengthen the work’s overall impact.
Conclusion: The study concludes that Muhammad: The Messenger of God is an exemplary model of the comprehensive and effective use of mise-en-scène in portraying the Infallibles. Imam Ali and other television productions, however, remain at a developmental stage in using mise-en-scène to depict religious figures. By tracing how this device has evolved across cinema and television, the study also sheds light on its influence on audience perception.
Keywords